
57 years ago, Genesis released their first LP. Compared to their later work, especially in the 1970s, this is chock full of concise songs, no meandering solos, plenty of piano and even a stab at a commercial single in the form Silent Sun. The record even came out in a mono as well as stereo mix. So, what is the story here.
The original line-up of Genesis formed in 1967 and consisted of guitarist Anthony Phillips, guitarist/bassist Mike Rutherford, lead vocalist/flutist Peter Gabriel, keyboardist Tony Banks, and drummer Chris Stewart, all pupils of Charterhouse School in Godalming, Surrey. At that time, it was quite unusual for a band to come out of the public school system, with the vast majority having been in the state sector. I digress.
Each member had been in earlier school bands with Gabriel, Banks, and Stewart in the Garden Wall. Phillips and Rutherfords’ band was known as Anon, which did get as far as recording a song called ‘Pennsylvania Flickhouse’ which has found it way out into the wild in 2011. After that band split, the two friends started writing songs together at Rutherford’s grandmother’s house. They asked Banks to play piano on a demo they were planning to record, and Banks agreed under the condition that they also record a song he and Gabriel had written. They ended up recording six songs for their demo tape which were ‘Don’t Want You Back’, Try A Little Sadness’, She’s Beautiful’, That’s Me’, Listen On Five’ and ‘Patricia’. Some of these would find their way onto compilations and reissues down the years. The members intended for the songs to be performed by other people as they saw themselves foremost as a collection of songwriters.
The group sent the demo tape to two people, one being BBC radio presenter David Jacobs, and the other was sent to former Charterhouse pupil Jonathan King, who had scored commercial success as a singer-songwriter and producer with his UK top five single ‘Everyone’s Gone To The Moon’ in 1965. Following a visit to the school during Old Boys Day, where the group had a friend give the tape to him, he listened to it in his car on his drive home and, despite its roughness, was immediately enthusiastic, particularly about Gabriel’s vocals. King offered the group a ten year publishing deal with his publishing company JonJo music and a five year recording contract to produce ten albums for Decca Records. However, after concerns from their band members parents, one due to the age of the members which ranged from between 15 and 17 years old and also because they were keen for their children to pursue careers away from music, this was reduced to a one year deal with the option for a second.
Between August and Decmber 1967, they recorded a selection of songs at Regent Sound Studios, London. The band were keen to attempt longer, more complex pieces but King advised them to focus on shorter, more pop orientated material. A bit annoyed by this, Banks and Gabriel came up with ‘The Silent Sun’, a pastiche of The Bee Gees who were one of King’s favourite bands. This song would be their first single. The producer also came up with their name, reflecting that it marked ‘a new sound and a new feeling’, or just because it was the start of something for him and the band. ‘The Silent Sun’ flopped, even though it had received some radio play on Radio Caroline and BBC Radio One.
In May 1968, the second single, ‘A Winter’s Tale’ backed with ‘One-Eyed Hound’, was released and, like their first, it flopped. Stewart then left the group either to continue with his studies, or because of his poor technique. He was replaced by John Silver. Despite their lack of success King continued to support the group and, by mid-1968, suggested that a studio album might reverse their fortunes. They were a little overwhelmed with the longer available time of an LP, so King suggested the idea of a loose concept album that told a story about the Book of Genesis at the start and the Book of Revelation at the end, with linked instrumental tracks. The idea worked, and the group began to write at a faster pace, composing more than enough material to return to Regent Sound studio 2 during the school summer holidays of 1968. These sessions would produce the album, ‘From Genesis To Revelation’.
King was the producer, and once the songs were recorded, string and brass arrangements were added by Arthur Greenslade and Lou Warburton. These were added to one of the stereo channels, while mixing the band’s performance on the other. This was done without the band’s knowledge, which they thought compromised the strength of the songs, and Phillips was particularly angered at the decision, expressing his feelings towards it by stomping out of the studio on the last day. His main issue was that due to the limitations of recording technology of the time, adding orchestration meant that everything else on the recording had to be reduced to mono.
The album was released in March 1969 and failed to chart, and even the release of ‘Where The Sour Turns To Sweet’ as a single failed to stimulate new interest. Prior to its release, Decca discovered that an American act had also called themselves Genesis and asked the band to change its name to avoid confusion, but King reached a compromise so the band’s name would be omitted from the sleeve, leaving the album’s title written in gold text in a Gothic style, in order to evoke mystery when presented in music shops. However, this reputedly back-fired when some shops filed the album in their religious music sections, since the title ‘From Genesis To Revelation’ was the only descriptive text on the album. The album is believed to have sold only sold 649 copies, and so original copies are now extremely rare (especially the mono mix), and when it failed to become a success, the group decided to split and resume their education.
Rutherford has said “Legend has it that From Genesis to Revelation ended up being shelved in the religious music section of record shops as a result, but the fact is we only sold 600 copies so it can’t have been in many record shops in any case. I can’t remember ever seeing it, and I did look”.
This marked the end of their association with King, who had grown increasingly dissatisfied with the band directing their material away from mainstream pop, and in September 1969, with the release of ‘When The Sour Turns To Sweet’ as a single. The bands’ association with Decca also finished with neither the label or band looking to renew it. Gabriel, Banks, Rutherford, and Phillips decided to make Genesis a full-time band, recruited John Mayhew on drums, obtained a recording contract with Charisma Records and the rest they say is history.
Disc 1
Mono LP mix, singles and demos from 1967
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (Mono)
- In The Beginning (Mono)
- Fireside Song (Mono)
- The Serpent (Mono)
- Am I Very Wrong? (Mono)
- In The Wilderness (Mono)
- The Conqueror (Mono)
- In Hiding (Mono)
- One Day (Mono)
- Window (Mono)
- In Limbo (Mono)
- The Silent Sun (Mono)
- A Place To Call My Own (Mono)
- The Silent Sun (Single A-Side – 7” Mix)
- That’s Me (Single B-Side)
- A Winter’s Tale (Single A-Side)
- One-Eyed Hound (Single B-Side)
- She Is Beautiful (Demo)
- Patricia (Demo)
- Try A Little Sadness (Demo)
Disc 2
Stereo mix, 1968 demos
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (Stereo)
- In The Beginning (Stereo)
- Fireside Song (Stereo)
- The Serpent (Stereo)
- Am I Very Wrong? (Stereo)
- In The Wilderness (Stereo)
- The Conqueror (Stereo)
- In Hiding (Stereo)
- One Day (Stereo)
- Window (Stereo)
- In Limbo (Stereo)
- The Silent Sun (Stereo)
- A Place To Call My Own (Stereo)
- Image Blown Out (Demo)
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (Demo)
- In The Beginning (Demo)
- The Magic Of Time (Demo)
- Hey! (Demo)
- Hidden In The World Of Dawn (Demo)
- Sea Bee (Demo)
- The Mystery Of The Flannel Isle Lighthouse (Demo)
- Hair On The Arms & Legs (Demo)
Disc 3
De-Orchestrated, rough mixes etc. As noted earlier, Anthony Phillips was particularly annoyed with the orchestration on this record. Some rough mixes have seen the light of day minus the strings and horns but what if the final mix had them removed. Well, the internet provides. Thanks to pj at https://albumsiwishexisted2.blogspot.com/ for posting it.
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (De-Orchestrated)
- In The Beginning (De-Orchestrated)
- Fireside Song (De-Orchestrated)
- The Serpent (De-Orchestrated)
- Am I Very Wrong? (De-Orchestrated)
- In The Wilderness (De-Orchestrated)
- The Conqueror (De-Orchestrated)
- In Hiding (De-Orchestrated)
- One Day (De-Orchestrated)
- Window (De-Orchestrated)
- In Limbo (De-Orchestrated)
- The Silent Sun (De-Orchestrated)
- A Place To Call My Own (De-Orchestrated)
- When The Sour Turns To Sweet (Rough Mix)
- In The Wilderness (Rough Mix Without Strings)
- One Day (Rough Mix)
- Image Blown Out (Rough Mix)
- Build Me A Mountain (Rough Mix)
Disc 4
2017 mixes made from the then ‘recently’ rediscovered multitrack tapes.
- In Hiding (Vocals Mix)
- One Day (New Stereo Mix)
- A Winter’s Tale (Studio Takes)
- A Place To Call My Own (Vocals Mix)
- The Silent Sun (New Mono Mix)
- In Hiding (New Stereo Mix)
- On The Trail Of The One Eyed Hound (New Stereo Mix)
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (New Mono Mix)
- A Place To Call My Own (New Mono Mix)
- One Day (Mono Mix With Reduced Horns)
- In Limbo (Mono Mix With Reduced Horns)
- Am I Very Wrong (Mono Mix With Reduced Horns)
- The Serpent (New Mono Mix)
- The Silent Sun (Alternative New Mono Mix)
- The Conqueror (New Mono Mix)
- Image Blown Out (Alternative Demo)
- That’s Me (New Mono Mix)
- In The Wilderness (New Mono Mix)
- The Window (New Mono Mix)
- In The Beginning (New Mono Mix)
- The Serpent (Vocals Mix)
- Fireside Song (New Mono Mix)
- Where The Sour Turns To Sweet (New Mono Mix)
I decided against included the 2006 version of ‘The Silent Sun’ and ‘When The Sour Turns to Sweat’ as both had new drums added to them and to my ears, they sound terrible.














