Month: January 2025

The Beach Boys had gone from being an act that performed songs about cars and surfing to producing the pop masterpiece of ‘Pet Sounds’ in the space of four years. Musicians and song writers moved quickly in the 1960’s. Just look how much Dylan and The Beatles changed their sounds in the same time. Anyway, with the collapse of the ’Smile’ project, (which I looked at in a previous post https://www.thesquirepresents.co.uk/the-beach-boys-smile-redux/), the band recorded the lo-fi album ‘Smiley Smile’, a record which showed that Brian Wilson’s control over the recording process was diminishing. 

The band had also dropped out of performing at the Monterey Pop Festival where the great and the good of the counterculture turned up to herald in a new age of music, something that with the failure of the ‘Smile’ album to appear meant that The Beach Boys were seen as out of step with the times. In response, the band booked the Honolulu International Centre Arena to perform a couple of concerts that that would lead to a live album and concert film. 

Things did not go smoothly. Bruce Johnson refused to go, saying that the whole situation had got too weird. To make up the numbers as it were, Brian Wilson was persuaded to go. Wilson had not performed live for nearly three years and said that he would come along if he could bring his Baldwin organ. This meant that he would not be covering bass duties as he had before which meant that Carl Wilson or Al Jardine would need to take on that responsibility. The band were also under rehearsed and this can be clearly heard on the recordings. To counteract this, the band tried overdubbing to rescue the recordings but these proved unsatisfactory. They then went to recording studio in San Fransisco to produce a ‘live’ record where the audience noise would be edited in later. These recordings were also abandoned as the band felt that it was ready to record what would become their ‘Wild Honey’ album. 

These recordings would remain in The Beach Boys vault until the early 80s when some of them started to see the light of day. Finally in 2017, both of the shows were released and it from these that this what if has been compiled. I have looked to include the best version of each song which was not an easy task as these performances are very poor. Most come from the second night but where they do not, I have marked them with an asterisk. 

It is clear to see why this was not released by just hearing it. The band not only sound underrehearsed but disinterested in what they are doing. Maybe they were too stoned? It also shows how ill equipped they were to perform the complex songs that Brian had been producing in the studio over the last couple of years in a live setting. This is by far the weakest what if album I have posted on the site. The Beach Boys would produce better live albums than this in future. 

Side 1

1. Hawthorne Boulevard
2. Hawaii
3. Help Me Rhonda
4. You’re So Good To Me
5. California Girls
6. Wouldn’t It Be Nice
7. Gettin’ Hungry*
8. Surfer Girl
9. Surfin’

Side 2

1. Sloop John B
2. The Letter
3. God Only Knows
4. Good Vibrations
5. Heroes & Villains
6. Barbara Ann*

The front cover was taken from https://idesignalbumcovers.tumblr.com

All performances from the 26th August 1967 Performance except where noted.

*25th August 1967 Performance

After 1983’s ‘The Final Cut’, it looked as though Pink Floyd were unlikely to release an album of new material any time soon, if at all. ‘The Final Cut’ was essentially a Roger Waters solo album and even though it was commercially successful, each band member spent the next couple of years releasing solo records. This included the no longer officially a member even though not everyone released it until seeing the lack of a credit for him on the back of ‘The Final Cut’, Rick Wright.  

Whatever the causes, the mid 80s would see a number of law suits flying about which would finally be resolved (sort of) by the end of 1987 by which time, the ‘Momentary Lapse of Reason’ album had been released which did not contain Roger Waters. With all that uncertainty, I am surprised to see that a compilation did not see the light of day during that period just to keep the Pink Floyd name alive. I therefore decided to have a go myself at putting together a spiritual follow up to their classic ‘Relics’ compilation from 1971. In a moment of inspiration, I decided that the name ‘More Relics’ would be a good choice. 

The original ‘Relics’ was a bit of a clearing house contains single A and B sides as none of these were included on any albums at the time, some album tracks and one unreleased song. I have tried to follow this but instead of album tracks, I decided to focus on some more rarities instead. So, what do we get. All of the 1960s singles that were not on the original ‘Relics’, some rare European single mixes, a couple of stray tracks and one unreleased song. 

Side A

1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond – Part 1 (French Jukebox Single Edit)
2. It Would Be So Nice (Single B-Side)
3. Apple & Oranges (Single A-Side)
4. Candy & A Current Bun (Single B-Side)
5. Wish You Were Here – with Stephane Grappelli (Previously Unreleased)
6. Point Me At The Sky (Single A-Side)

Side B

1. Pigs On The Wing – Parts 1 & 2 (8 Track Version)
2. Money (1981 Promo Single Edit)
3. Young Lust (Italian Single Version)
4. Another Brick In The Wall (Single Version)
5. Embryo
6. Give Birth To A Smile

Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 1) – Released as a single in France. 

It Would Be So Nice – The first single A-Side to be released that was not written by Syd Barrett, even though the band were still trying to channel his way of writing. It didn’t chart and many members of the band thought it was down to it being awful. 

Apple & Oranges  – The last A-Side recorded with Syd Barrett and their first not to chart in the UK. Roger Waters blamed the production and it does sound a bit of a mess. 

Candy & A Current Bun – B-Side to their debut single, ‘Arnold Layne’. 

Wish You Were Here – with Stéphane Grappelli– The one previously unreleased song on the compilation. An alternative version of the classic ‘Wish You Were Here’ with added violin by legendary player, Stéphane Grappelli. It could be argued that this is a better version than the one that was originally released. 

Point Me At The Sky – The last single released by Pink Floyd in the UK during the 1960’s. Roger Waters called it a ‘notable failure’ and that the band would therefore concentrate on albums because they were ‘no bloody good’ at writing singles.  

Pigs On The Wing – Parts 1 & 2  – Originally released on the ‘Animals’ album. On there, the song was divided into two parts which bookended the LP. When the 8-Track cartridge version was prepared, it was decided to make use of the loop-play function of that format which is where the end of the recording looped back to the beginning. This meant that the album could be played continuously. Part 1 and Part 2 were therefore edited together and a linking guitar solo added, which was played by touring guitar player, Snowy White. 

Money – This version of ‘Money’ was re-recorded for the compilation, ‘A Collection of Great Dance Songs’. Dave Gilmour recorded the whole track because one record label would not give the rights to another one to release the original version, or something along this lines. Gilmour played every instrument on the track himself except for the sax part. That was recorded by Dick Parry who had played the part on the original recording. This version came out on a promo single. 

Young Lust  – Released in Italy on the B-Side of their version of ‘Another Brick In The Wall’, this extended version of the song which runs to 3 minute and 58 seconds. It restores the full 12-bar intro which was cut during production. It also has the full, clean outro without the phone call. At about the 2 minute and 50 second mark as the guitar solo ends, a scream can be heard. This is Roger Waters and it was mixed out of most other versions.

Another Brick In The Wall (Part 2) – The single version of the song which was their first single in the UK for over twelve years. It was also their biggest hit in the UK (and many other markets) when it hit the Number 1 spot. 

Embryo – Record in late 1968 and possibly unfinished. It would be released on a couple of compilations. The first being the Harvest Sampler LP, ‘Picnic – A Breath of Fresh Air’ and the US compilation, ‘Works’. This was a concert table for a couple of years in the early 1970s. 

Give Birth To A Smile – Taken from the soundtrack album, ‘Music Form The Body’. This was composed and performed by Roger Waters and Ron Geesin but the last song on the LP features the remaining members of pink Floyd. 

The album cover is from the Behance website and was created blu Javi Montilla. 

As an added bonus, I did have a second ‘More Relics’ sleeve prepared. Like the original ‘Relics’, this is a hand drawing. This one could be seen as an alternative sleeve for the South American market.

Welcome to 2025 and here is a project I have been looking forward to sharing. Anthony Phillips was the original guitar player in Genesis, playing on their first two albums. ‘From Genesis To Revelation’ and ‘Tresspass’ with his tenure lasting from 1967 to 1970. It was he who was most instrumental in the band becoming professional and a live band. They had not supported their first album with live shows as Phillips, as well as vocalist Peter Gabriel were still at school at the time. The irony of this was that Phillips would develop stage fright. He thought the stage fright would pass but that and a case of bronchial pneumonia brought about his departure from the band. Phillips kept in touch with the his old band mates, and would continue to write with Mike Rutherford. He would also collaborate with Harry Williamson (son of Tarka the Otter author, Henry Williamson) as well as training as a music teacher, studyed orchestration and continuing to write music.

Throughout the seven year period between leaving Genesis and releasing his first solo album, Philips would continue to record demos and was looking to work on a project with old band mate Mike Rutherford. The pair would meet up sporadically due to Rutherford’s commitments to Genesis. The first fruits of this collaboration to partially see the light of day was ‘Silver Song’, a song that the pair had written in 1969 as a farewell to departing Genesis drummer, John Silver. Phillips and Rutherford brought in Phil Collins who was then in the Genesis drummer’s stool to not only provide percussion, but lead vocals. A B-Side was quickly written in the form of ‘Only Your Love’ but with everything ready to go, the Charisma label who had financed the recordings decided against releasing the record. To this day, no one is sure why. 

However, what if this single was scheduled for a release in 1975 when Genesis were taking a break after the Lamb Lies Down on Broadway tour and the departure of vocalist Peter Gabriel? This could be the prelude to an Anthony Phillips solo album to be released the same year, two years before his official 1977 debut, ‘The Geese & The Ghost’. But what should be on it?

Well, since 2014 Cherry Red Records and the people who have been curating Phillips’ tape archive have been doing a sterling job re-releasing his back catalogue. Each set comes with one disc of unreleased material which is of such a high quality, I am surprised these have not seen the light of day before. I was also surprised by the amount of material that has come out that was written and recorded before 1977 that was not included on his first album. 

With this album following on from the proposed 1975 release of the ‘Silver Song’, this was going to be a a more stripped down affair due to the fact that Mike Rutherford would not have been able to spend much, if any time with Phillips due to his commitments to Genesis and the ‘Lamb Lies Down on Broadway’ Tour. I also looked to follow the template of ‘Geese & the Ghost, so we get some vocal and instrumental tracks. Very few of these songs have been re-recorded since they were laid down in demo form. One that did see the light of day before was a re-recording of ‘Stranger’ which appears on the first ‘Private Parts & Pieces’. Another was ‘Take This Heart’ which would be recorded in 1975 by the Charterhouse Choral Society for the Charisma release, ‘Beyond An Empty Dream’. That version is very different from the original demo. As the majority of these are demo recordings, some of the fidelity is not studio quality. However, these are the only recordings I had to work with. 

Side A

1. Queen Bettine (1972 Demo)
2. Picardy Pictures (1972 Demo)
3. Rowey Song (1972 Version)
4. Child Song (1973 Demo)
5. Stranger (1970 Demo)

Side B

1. Guitar Song (1973 Demo)
2. Variation On A Theme Of Fantoms (1973 Demo)
3. Windmill (1971 Demo)
4. Take This Heart (1972 Demo)
5. Rowey Reprise (1972 Version)
6. Master Of Time (1973 Demo)
7. Will The Last Man Off The Ice Rink (Please Turn Out The Lights) (Recorded 1973) 

Single

1. Silver Song (Recorded 1973)
2. Only Your Love (Recorded 1973)

None of the songs really lent themselves to a title except for ‘Variation on a Theme of Fantoms’ so I decided that should be what the album you’d have been called. Phillips has used the artist Peter Cross for many of his sleeves, but I did not have a piece of his artwork I could use. I therefore used a picture I took on a very cold December morning near the village of Moggerhanger, Bedfordshire in the UK.

I was not able to recreate this playlist on Spotify.